
Case Study
How Nottingham Building Society set up its governance for growth
Backed by over 175 years of trust and purpose, Nottingham Building Society is a future-focused organisation fighting to help people save, prepare for the future, and own homes in a way that is fit for real life. It serves members through 31 branches across eight counties, alongside its digital and intermediary channels, and reached a record £5.4 billion in total assets at the end of 2025.
The society had identified its governance structure as an area to review as part of its wider transformation. With ambitious growth plans and a full board and committee calendar to support, it required external capacity and an independent perspective to support with the review and recommendations to its Executive Committee.
At a glance
|
Client |
Nottingham Building Society |
|
Geography |
Nottingham, UK |
|
Sector |
Financial services, mutual building society |
|
Organisation |
A 177-year-old mutual with an ambitious strategy fighting to help people save for their goals the way they choose and support aspiring homeowners, and a governance team balancing a major review against day-to-day board support and other governance accountabilities. |
|
What Changed |
Board Intelligence's advisory team worked with the society on a holistic review of its governance structure, covering all committee levels. The work included peer benchmarking that went beyond what public filings reveal, a clear sequence for the decisions that needed taking, and support in shaping the paper that went to the Executive Committee. |
|
Impact |
Every recommendation was approved by the Executive Committee. The society now has a clear frame for implementation through the final quarter of 2026 and into 2027. |
The challenge
Too much governance, or the right amount?
Nottingham Building Society has big ambitions and wants to reach them quickly for an organisation of its age and in its sector. Governance can enable that or constrain it, and the society wanted to know which it was doing.
Have we set ourselves up for failure by having either too much governance or too many layers of governance, or just not right sizing it for where we are as an organisation now, but also where we want to get to in the future?”
Matty Pownall-Shipman, Deputy Society Secretary, Nottingham Building Society
These were the questions Matty Pownall-Shipman, Deputy Society Secretary at Nottingham Building Society, set out to answer.
The team had set a stretching objective to reduce the time spent in committee meetings by empowering Execs and the Leadership Team to make decisions and move faster, subject to sensible guardrails. As the work took shape, the scope grew to take in culture and ways of working, not just hours in a diary.
Capacity was one constraint. Company secretarial teams carry a heavy business-as-usual load, and finding time for forward-looking, strategic work alongside it is difficult. The other was the depth of insight the Execs and Board needed to make an informed decision. Directors wanted to know what their peers were doing, and there is only so much that can be drawn from public-facing documents. The society wanted benchmarking that went deeper than that, and an independent partner to support the process.
The approach
A partnership, not a handover
Board Intelligence's advisory team scoped a targeted piece of work within clear budget parameters, designed to take the society to the next phase of the review rather than to deliver everything at once.
Onboarding was quick on both sides. The team got up to speed through conversations with the governance team and by reading the society’s governance documents, picking up the contextual challenges and the priorities of individual committee chairs.
The work was sequenced deliberately. Peer benchmarking first, then the shape of the recommendations, then the paper itself. The advisory team acted as a sounding board throughout, testing ideas and setting out what good looks like, while the society retained ownership of how its own business runs.
We weren’t looking for a person to do a job. It was a partnership approach, which has worked really well.”
Matty Pownall-Shipman, Deputy Society Secretary, Nottingham Building Society
The engagement had exposure at the highest levels of the society, including the Chief Executive, Chief Financial Officer, and Chief Risk Officer.
Impact
Recommendations approved, and a clear path to implementation
The Executive Committee approved every recommendation. There was a full discussion of how best to implement them, but no debate about whether they were the right things to be looking at, and the benchmarking behind them supported both the problem statement and how best to solve it.
The society is now implementing the changes through the final quarter of 2026 and into 2027. Implementation has brought the challenges any change programme brings. What hasn’t been in question, however, is the plan. “What’s not a challenge is the clarity of the recommendations and the approvals that we’ve got,” Matty says. “Clarity, I think, is the key.”
The society has plans to undertake a training programme for Execs and the Leadership Team on preparing good Board & Committee materials in 2027, and will be exploring how Board Intelligence could support.
Ultimately, we managed to achieve the goal of this work programme, and Board Intelligence’s support made it feel possible to get there.”
Matty Pownall-Shipman, Deputy Society Secretary, Nottingham Building Society
Why this matters
Governance structures tend to grow rather than get designed. Committees are added, terms of reference expand, and the layers accumulate until the structure reflects the organisation’s history rather than its ambitions.
Board Intelligence's Board Value Index found that rigid or inconsistent decision-making processes and frameworks are the single biggest barrier to board decision-making, cited by 34% of directors globally, ahead of clarity of roles and responsibilities at 32% and the quality of information provided to the board at 29%. Those are barriers created by how a board is set up to work, not by the quality of the people around the table. Getting the structure right is what lets a board take the decisions its ambitions depend on.
For an organisation with growth ambitions, the obstacle is rarely knowing that a governance review would help. It’s finding the capacity, the external benchmark, and the independent voice to get it done and get it approved. The right structure gives a board clarity, confidence, and the level of oversight that fits where the business is heading.
Work with Board Intelligence's advisory team to strengthen your board, align it with leadership, and turn strategy into results.
Find out more
More case studies for you
Trusted by 85,000+ board members, executives, and governance professionals.
























